The Securities and Exchange Commission (S.E.C.) has authority to investigate violations of federal securities laws and commence enforcement actions if its investigations uncover evidence of wrongdoing. Initially, the S.E.C.'s statutory authority was limited to seeking an injunction barring any future violations. Beginning in the 1970's, however, courts began granting the S.E.C.'s requests for disgorgement in enforcement proceedings. Disgorgement is a remedy which requires defendants to repay any unlawful monetary gains. Although Congress has since authorized the S.E.C. to seek monetary civil penalties, the S.E.C. has continued to seek disgorgement.

The United States Supreme Court recently ruled that claims for disgorgement in an S.E.C. enforcement action must be filed within a five-year statute of limitations. The Court's decision turned on whether disgorgement is a penalty or an equitable remedy, and the court determined it was the former. The ruling will effectively require S.E.C. enforcement staff to complete investigations in a shorter amount of time. Moreover, the designation of disgorgement as a penalty could limit the amount the S.E.C. can seek as a civil monetary penalty on top of any money disgorged. However, the holding of the case and its direct implications are not the real headline.

A literal footnote in the decision could have a much greater impact than the decision itself. It states that "nothing in this opinion should be interpreted as an opinion on whether courts possess authority to order disgorgement in S.E.C. enforcement proceedings or on whether courts have properly applied disgorgement principles in this context." As such, the Court made a point to say that it has not determined that courts should be ordering disgorgement at all in this context. Importantly, the federal securities law does not list disgorgement as one of the remedies available to the S.E.C.

In 1971, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an order requiring defendants to repay profits made by trading on confidential information, as an exercise of the equitable powers of a court to prevent wrongdoing. Ever since, the S.E.C. routinely seeks this remedy and courts routinely grant it. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court's footnote may have opened the door to arguments by defense lawyers that disgorgement is not a permissible remedy in a S.E.C. enforcement proceedings.

The answer to whether disgorgement in securities cases is permissible will involve an inquiry as to whether an English chancery court in 1789 (when Congress adopted the Judiciary Act that gave federal courts the power to hear lawsuits "in equity") had the power to order that remedy. If the remedy was not an exercise of a court's inherent authority back in 1789, then disgorgement would not be a permissible exercise of the equitable powers of a court to prevent wrongdoing. However, Congress could resolve the question by specifically authorizing disgorgement as an available remedy in any S.E.C. enforcement action. If you have questions about this article or would like to speak to Attorney Sally P. McDonald, please call 401-824-5100, or email her at [email protected]. We welcome your comments, questions and suggestions.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Our Firm And Schedule A Consultation

Work with our experienced team of lawyers. Call 866-353-3310 or email us today to schedule a consultation.

View Office Locations

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Email Us For A Response

Rhode Island
Northwoods Office Park
1301 Atwood Ave.
Suite 215 N
Johnston, RI 02919

Toll Free: 866-353-3310
Phone: 401-824-5100
Fax: 401-824-5123
Map & Directions

One International Place
Suite 1400
Boston, MA 02110

Toll Free: 866-353-3310
Fax: 866-353-5020
Map & Directions

Wells Fargo Plaza
925 South Federal Highway
Suite 715
Boca Raton, FL 33432

Phone: 561-362-2030
Fax: 866-353-5020
Map & Directions

901 Main Street
Suite O
Osterville, MA 02655

Phone: 508-420-7159
Fax: 508-420-7162
Map & Directions

GPS Directions to this office: 555 Valley Street, Providence, RI 02908